FW: Wisconsin Rent Control proposed by leading gubernatorial candidate

David Crowley, our leading gubernatorial candidate, is proposing a number of onerous changes to Wisconsin landlord-tenant law, including rent control. Some of his “proposals” have been law for decades.
His six proposals are below. A couple of comments on them:
1. Local governments can and do regularly inspect rental housing. In the past, municipalities used rental inspections as a profit center. Ten years ago, we passed a statute prohibiting excessive municipal fees. Milwaukee recently adopted an inspection program that complies with the statute. Courts often appoint receivers when buildings are abandoned or mismanaged. 2. Rent control. Mr. Crowley ignores that operating costs, including insurance, taxes, labor, and materials, have spiraled out of control. 3. For 49 years, WI has had a prohibition against retaliatory actions in response to complaints. Rent withholding has been our law for decades. 4. Crime and DV victim protections were enacted over a decade ago, with support from our association and the Realtors. Millions of dollars per year fund eviction defense attorneys. Cases are automatically sealed after two years if a writ was not issued. Judges have sealed thousands of evictions, including those with writs and some with large monetary judgments. 5. 5. WI law has capped application fees at $25, based on the actual credit report charge. WI has required full disclosure of rent or non-rent charges the tenant must pay since 1998. (ATCP 134.09(9)(a)2) The WI DOJ has enforced this provision against many owners for decades. 6. DATCP has had full power to enforce landlord-tenant laws since 1978. Last year they settled a case against an owner for $1.7M. Prior cases have resulted in judgments of $500,000, which would increase to 1.6M if there is no compliance, and one case that resulted in jail time for failing to send a deposit letter, despite the tenant owing more rent than their deposit.
Proposals for student housing are even worse.www.crowleyforwi.com/housing
David’s plan: 1. Let cities protect their residents again
* Repeal the state preemptions that stop local governments from policing rental housing. Cities could once again run proactive inspection and rental licensing programs, set fees that cover their costs, pull licenses from chronic violators, and ask a court to appoint a manager when an owner abandons a building.
2. Stop runaway rent increases
* Cap annual rent increases at 7 percent plus inflation, never more than 10 percent, with 90 days’ notice. Buildings less than 15 years old and owner-occupied duplexes through fourplexes would be exempt, so the cap protects renters without discouraging new construction.
3. Make repairs happen
* When a landlord ignores a written repair request, tenants could pay rent to the court until the work is done, or make urgent repairs to heat, water, electricity, and locks and deduct the cost. Landlords who raise rent or file for eviction after a tenant complains would face strong penalties for retaliation.
4. Bring fairness to evictions
* Give tenants 14 days, not 5, to catch up on rent. Require a legitimate reason to end or refuse to renew a tenancy in larger buildings, with relocation help when a tenant must move through no fault of their own. Restore the duty to store belongings, protect innocent tenants and crime victims from criminal-activity evictions, fund access to a lawyer in eviction court, and seal eviction records when a case is dismissed or the tenant wins.
5. End junk fees and rent-fixing software
* Require advertised rent to include every mandatory fee. Limit application fees to the actual cost of screening and cap late fees. Ban software that sets rents using competitors’ private pricing data.
6. Restore enforcement
* Give the Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection full authority to act on violations of landlord-tenant law, and fund local tenant resource centers so renters know their rights.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *